Business information

Own this company?

Claim & Respond

Reviews with responses attract 🔥59% more returning customers and 🔥20% more first-time customers

Category:

Clothing

Each brand on RealReviews.io belongs to a specific category, where it holds a position in the top rankings. The ranking is determined by various factors, such as the overall rating on the site, the number of reviews, the business's activity in managing reviews, engagement with customers, and more.

CottonMill.com is 154 out of 331 best companies in Clothing on RealReviews.io

Customer reviews

Sort

  • Sort by:
  • By relevance
  • By date
  • By rating (low to high)
  • By rating (high to low)

Summary

CottonMill.com has a 4.3 - star rating from 22 reviews, indicating a high level of customer satisfaction!

  • 5 stars

    70%

    15 reviews

    15 reviews

  • 4 stars

    9%

    2 reviews

    2 reviews

  • 3 stars

    13%

    3 reviews

    3 reviews

  • 2 stars

    4%

    1 reviews

    1 reviews

  • 1 stars

    4%

    1 reviews

    1 reviews

  • A

    Anonymous

    1 reviews

    Solid experience at the cotton mill tonight.

    Solid experience at the cotton mill tonight. Excellent service from the start, very friendly welcome. Leanne greeted us warmly, seated promptly, drinks arrived quickly. Food came in 20 mins, tasty for the cost, despite a limited menu. Recommended!

    0 comments

    Replying to Anonymous

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • R

    Ronewa

    1 reviews

    I am satisfied with the hoodies I purchased

    I am satisfied with the hoodies I purchased recently for my friends and the service is very good. I was pleased when they mentioned we can also shop online.

    0 comments

    Replying to Ronewa

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • L

    LaRita

    1 reviews

    Bought second heavy duty cotn

    Bought second heavy duty cotn sweatshirt for my husbund; appreciate the good qualiti, heavy cotton in a hooded sweatshirt. The new brick colr is pleasing!

    0 comments

    Replying to LaRita

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • m

    maryann

    1 reviews

    Simple website to navigate.

    Simple website to navigate. Orders arrive fast. Items appear as described. Nice variety of ladies' apparel. I like the cotton fabric used in the clothes. However, items are frequently out of stock for a long time.

    0 comments

    Replying to maryann

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • R

    Robin

    1 reviews

    Item arrived ahead of schedule, which was great

    Item arrived ahead of schedule, which was great. Unfortunately, it was the wrong item. However, the return process was easy and straightforward. Overall, the experience was mixed, but the efficient return process was appreciated.

    0 comments

    Replying to Robin

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • Reviews from other countries:

  • D

    Destiny Kearney

    1 reviews

    United States

    Walking into Cottonmill feels like

    Walking into Cottonmill feels like a treat every time. Their collection of women's clothing strikes the perfect balance between style and comfort. It’s rare to find outfits that look this good and feel even better. The quality? Just outstanding. But what really makes the experience memorable is the staff. They’re genuinely friendly and always ready to help, making the shopping experience so pleasant. You know that feeling when you find a place that just gets it right? That’s Cottonmill for you. If you’re looking for a wardrobe refresh that won’t disappoint, this is the spot. Couldn't recommend it more for anyone looking to add some flair and comfort to their closet!

    0 comments

    Replying to Destiny Kearney

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • share

    Review Your Experience.

    Share Your Thoughts and Leave a Review

    Write a review
  • S

    S. Fain

    1 reviews

    United States

    I've been shopping at Cotton

    I've been shopping at Cotton Mill for quite some time now, and their ruffled cover-up is just another winner in my wardrobe. Seriously, their clothes are like magic or something because no matter how many times I toss them in the wash, they always come out looking fresh and new. It's like they never age! This cover-up is super comfy and keeps me cool, especially on those hot days when you just can't deal with heavy fabrics. It's quickly become a go-to piece for me. I appreciate how effortless it is to look put together with their clothes. Cotton Mill definitely knows how to keep a customer happy with quality that lasts.

    0 comments

    Replying to S. Fain

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • A

    Alaya Callahan

    1 reviews

    United Kingdom

    I went there last weekend

    I went there last weekend and it was quite the experience. The atmosphere was so welcoming, you just feel it right when you walk in. The staff seemed genuinely friendly, not that forced kind of nice you sometimes get. The menu had loads of options, which was great, but it made deciding a bit tough! Eventually, I picked a pasta dish, and wow, it was amazing—creamy and flavorful, just how I like it. The portion size was perfect too, not too much but definitely enough to satisfy. I also tried one of their desserts, and let's just say it was the cherry on top of a great meal. Definitely a place I'd go back to again.

    0 comments

    Replying to Alaya Callahan

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • M

    Michelle Smith

    1 reviews

    United States

    You won't believe the gem

    You won't believe the gem I found! This place is like a treasure chest of unique, stylish pieces. It's not your typical store where everything looks the same. I spent hours browsing through their fantastic selection, and every corner had something special. The staff? Just amazing. They weren't just there to sell; they genuinely cared and helped me find exactly what I was looking for. It's rare to find such friendly and helpful people these days. If you're on the hunt for something different and fashionable, this is the spot. Honestly, can't wait to go back and see what new finds they'll have next time.

    0 comments

    Replying to Michelle Smith

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • P

    PM

    1 reviews

    Stumbled upon these sweatpants and

    Stumbled upon these sweatpants and shorts, and honestly, I'm pretty impressed. The fabric is gorgeous and feels super sturdy. You can tell it's made well, which is rare to find in 100% cotton nowadays. It's like discovering a hidden gem. However, dealing with customer service has been a bit of a rollercoaster. There were times when they were absolutely fantastic, but then there were moments when they really dropped the ball. If only their customer service matched the quality of their products, they'd be unbeatable. Overall, still happy with my purchase, just wish the support was more consistent.

    0 comments

    Replying to PM

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • J

    Joe Silvia

    1 reviews

    United States

    I'm pretty impressed

    I snagged a couple of items from my favorite store, and I gotta say, I'm pretty impressed with their stuff. The delivery? Super quick, as always. But here's the thing: the sizing is a bit off. I got a pullover sweatshirt and a zip-up, both in medium, thinking they'd fit the same. Nope! The sweatshirt was perfect, but the zip-up felt like it was made for someone bigger. Had to reorder the zip-up in small, and now it fits just right. It's a tiny hiccup in an otherwise awesome shopping experience. Still, totally worth it for the quality and service. Just a heads up for anyone else shopping there!

    0 comments

    Replying to Joe Silvia

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • share

    Review Your Experience.

    Share Your Thoughts and Leave a Review

    Write a review
  • P

    Patricia Rains

    1 reviews

    United States

    I was browsing online and

    I was browsing online and stumbled upon Cotton Mill, where I've been getting my cotton clothes for years. Imagine my surprise when I found out they might be closing soon. I quickly ordered a couple of items, hoping to snag them before it’s too late. To my delight, the package arrived faster than I thought it would, which made me really happy. I've always loved their cotton clothing, and the thought of them closing down is honestly a bit sad. If you haven't tried their stuff yet, you might want to check them out while you still can. Trust me, it’s worth it.

    0 comments

    Replying to Patricia Rains

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • P

    PM

    1 reviews

    United States

    These are definitely worth checking out

    I gotta say, these products are top-notch. I own both the sweatpants and the shorts, and I’m really happy with them. The design is spot-on, and the fabric is super durable and looks great. Honestly, these are the best 100% cotton pants I've come across. However, the customer service could use some improvement. It's not terrible, but there's definitely room for better. But the quality of the products makes up for it. If you’re looking for well-made, stylish, and comfy pants, these are definitely worth checking out.

    0 comments

    Replying to PM

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • J

    Joseph

    1 reviews

    I recently got some sweats

    I recently got some sweats from this place, and wow, they're exactly what I've been needing for the gym! They’re super high quality and have that perfect loose and warm feel. I was worried about the shipping time, but they arrived pretty fast, probably because I'm not too far from their warehouse. Even if they took a bit longer, they'd still be worth the wait. The comfort and fit are spot on, making my workouts so much better. Highly recommend checking them out if you're in need of some good gym clothes.

    0 comments

    Replying to Joseph

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • W

    Wendy from Vermont

    1 reviews

    I was so excited to

    I was so excited to get another pair of those awesome pants I ordered before, but I messed up and picked the wrong item. Total facepalm moment. But Cottonmill really came through for me. Returning the wrong pants was a breeze—no hassle at all. Then I got the right ones without any fuss. Seriously, their customer service is top-notch, and the products are just as great. Now I’ve got the pants I wanted, and I’m super happy with them. Can't wait to shop there again!

    0 comments

    Replying to Wendy from Vermont

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • j

    jmadams

    1 reviews

    United States

    Got myself a new jacket

    Got myself a new jacket from this brand, replacing the one I got way back in 2017. The old one's cuffs were pretty beat up. This jacket's got some weight to it, and it keeps me really warm. You can tell it's high quality the moment you put it on. It's actually made in Canada, which is cool. Feels like this one will last me a good long while too. Definitely worth checking out if you need something reliable and cozy for the colder months.

    0 comments

    Replying to jmadams

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • share

    Review Your Experience.

    Share Your Thoughts and Leave a Review

    Write a review
  • M

    Malakai Christianson

    1 reviews

    Poland

    It’s pretty awesome

    I got this product, and I gotta say, it’s pretty awesome. Fits perfectly and feels super comfy. The shipping was surprisingly quick too. It’s always a plus when you buy from a U.S. brand, you know? Everything seems really well-made. If anything comes up, I’ll make sure to update.

    0 comments

    Replying to Malakai Christianson

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • D

    Dylan

    1 reviews

    United States

    Super friendly

    I recently visited this women's clothing store, and wow, what a surprise! The selection was amazing, with styles that cater to just about every taste and occasion. The staff were super friendly, always ready to help without being pushy. I loved how the store was organized—easy to find what I wanted, and even discovered a few unexpected gems. Sizes seemed pretty true, which is always a win. Prices were reasonable, considering the quality, which was top notch. I did feel the fitting rooms could use a bit more space, but overall, it was a really great shopping experience. Definitely a place I’ll be returning to. If you're looking for something stylish and unique, this spot's worth checking out!

    0 comments

    Replying to Dylan

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • G

    Geraldine McMahan

    1 reviews

    United States

    When I ordered three jacket

    When I ordered three jacket shirts, I was pretty sure I was getting a bright blue, or that's what the website showed. But the color I chose was actually 'coffee,' and that's what I received. No complaints there! After the first wash, though, there were fabric bits everywhere—like a fabric confetti party in my machine! Double rinsed, and even then, the dryer sheets went into overdrive. And those buttonholes? Way too small, couldn't get the buttons through. I’ll need to carefully clip them wider, hoping I don’t mess up the stitching. Bit of a hassle, honestly, but overall, the color was right!

    0 comments

    Replying to Geraldine McMahan

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • P

    Phoebe

    1 reviews

    United States

    I wandered into Cotton Mill

    I wandered into Cotton Mill the other day, just browsing around. They've got a decent range of women's clothes, but honestly, the quality didn't quite blow me away. The staff? Super nice, always ready to help, but the store layout felt kinda cramped, like they tried to squeeze in too much. Prices won't break the bank, so that's a plus. I mean, it's an okay spot if you're nearby, but don't expect to be wowed. It's one of those places that's alright for a quick stop, but I wouldn't go outta my way to visit again. There's room for improvement, for sure!

    0 comments

    Replying to Phoebe

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • M

    Michelle Johnson

    1 reviews

    United Kingdom

    Visited the Cotton Mill in

    Visited the Cotton Mill in Newcastle for Christmas lunch today. The place itself was really lovely, and the staff were super friendly and helpful. The starter was absolutely amazing, and the dessert was also a hit. But, the main meal? It was pretty disappointing. Felt like it definitely wasn't worth the money. I had high hopes, but it just didn't live up to them. Sadly, I don't think I'll be going back.

    0 comments

    Replying to Michelle Johnson

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

  • share

    Review Your Experience.

    Share Your Thoughts and Leave a Review

    Write a review
  • L

    Loraine Baker

    1 reviews

    United States

    Man, I’ve tried ordering from

    Man, I’ve tried ordering from this place four times this year, and every single time I had to send stuff back. The sizing info is just wild – like, how can two different sizes have the same measurements? It's like playing a guessing game every time. And don't get me started on their customer service. There's no phone number to call, and when I tried to reach out online, it felt like I was talking to a wall. Never heard back. It’s just frustrating when all you want is to find something that fits without all this hassle. Wish they'd sort out their sizing and actually respond to customers.

    0 comments

    Replying to Loraine Baker

    The comment must be at least 10 characters.

Rating on other websites

  • Trustpilot

    4.8

  • Sitejabber

    3.0

  • Tripadvisor

    4.0

Business information

Own this company?

Claim & Respond

Reviews with responses attract 🔥59% more returning customers and 🔥20% more first-time customers

Category:

Clothing

Each brand on RealReviews.io belongs to a specific category, where it holds a position in the top rankings. The ranking is determined by various factors, such as the overall rating on the site, the number of reviews, the business's activity in managing reviews, engagement with customers, and more.

CottonMill.com is 154 out of 331 best companies in Clothing on RealReviews.io

About CottonMill.com

CottonMill.com is an online retailer specializing in 100% North American made cotton clothing. The company offers a wide range of garments for both men and women, including pants, tops, and kaftan dresses. Cotton Mill emphasizes quality and comfort, with products made exclusively in the USA and Canada. The website features bestsellers, new arrivals, and a blog that provides insights into the benefits and history of cotton clothing. Based in Pennsylvania, Cotton Mill is dedicated to promoting locally made, high-quality cotton apparel.

Key Details:

  • Location: The company is headquartered in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, United States.
  • Founders: CottonMill.com was founded by Ed Reiman.
  • Foundation Date: The company was established in the year 1992.
  • Translation language
Visit website